Search HexFastener

Find the part. Understand the spec.

Engineering Guide · 4 min read

Hardening Thicker Sections: SAE 4037, 4130, 4140 and 5140 (J404)

SAE 4037, 4135, 4137, 4140, 4142, 4145 and 5140 compared: Mo-only, chromium and CrMo families, composition ranges and heat-treatment choices.

November 15, 2026HexFastener

The short answer: SAE 4037 uses molybdenum, 51xx grades use chromium, and 41xx grades combine chromium and molybdenum to support hardening through a component’s section.

A bolt can have a hard surface and still miss its required core condition. Once section size becomes the limiting factor, chromium and molybdenum give the heat treater more options than raising carbon alone.

4037, 51xx and 41xx: three alloy designs

SAE J404 covers alloy-steel compositions. Within the groups discussed here, 40xx identifies molybdenum steels, 51xx chromium steels, and 41xx chromium–molybdenum steels. 4037 is therefore a Mo steel; 4140 combines Cr and Mo. Both belong in a fastener-material discussion, but their alloy designs differ. [1] [2]

Chromium and molybdenum increase hardenability. Molybdenum also helps resist softening during tempering. Compared with plain-carbon 1035–1050 steels, these additions can support the desired structure deeper into a section and give a different balance after tempering. Actual results depend on the grade, size and heat-treatment cycle. [3] [4]

Composition of 4037 and the 4130–4150 family

The selected ranges below separate carbon from the deliberately added Cr and Mo. “—” means that no intentional alloy range is listed for that element in the source row.

GradeC (%)Mn (%)Cr (%)Mo (%)
40370.35–0.400.70–0.90—0.20–0.30
41300.28–0.330.40–0.600.80–1.100.15–0.25
41350.33–0.380.70–0.900.80–1.100.15–0.25
41370.35–0.400.70–0.900.80–1.100.15–0.25
41400.38–0.430.75–1.000.80–1.100.15–0.25
41420.40–0.450.75–1.000.80–1.100.15–0.25
41450.43–0.480.75–1.000.80–1.100.15–0.25
41500.48–0.530.75–1.000.80–1.100.15–0.25

Heat analysis, mass percent; selected elements, not a complete purchase specification. Selected producer-handbook ranges labeled SAE J404-09. Si 0.15–0.35%, P ≤0.030%, S ≤0.040%. A dash means no deliberate Cr alloy range is listed; residual chromium can still be present. [2]

4037 and 4137 share the displayed C and Mn intervals. 4137 adds 0.80–1.10% Cr and uses a different Mo interval. Within the 41xx group, 4130 contains less carbon and manganese than 4140; 4142, 4145 and 4150 move the carbon interval upward while retaining the displayed Cr/Mo ranges. [2]

Where 5120, 5140 and 5160 fit

The 51xx branch supplies chromium without a listed intentional molybdenum addition. Its lower-carbon members serve different heat-treatment routes from its medium- and higher-carbon members.

GradeC (%)Mn (%)Cr (%)
51200.17–0.220.70–0.900.70–0.90
51300.28–0.330.70–0.900.80–1.10
51320.30–0.350.60–0.800.75–1.00
51400.38–0.430.70–0.900.70–0.90
51500.48–0.530.70–0.900.70–0.90
51600.56–0.640.75–1.000.70–0.90

Heat analysis, mass percent; selected elements, not a complete purchase specification. Selected chromium steels; no intentional Mo range is listed for these rows. Si 0.15–0.35%, P ≤0.030%, S ≤0.040% in the source. [2]

5120 is a lower-carbon candidate for case-hardening applications. 5140 sits near 4140’s carbon interval, making it a useful composition comparison when assessing the role of molybdenum. 5160 carries substantially more carbon and belongs toward the spring-steel end of the range. The selected grade still needs to match the part specification. [5]

The figure below compares three different alloy strategies around a medium-carbon composition.

4037, 5140 and 4140 separate Mo-only, Cr-only and CrMo alloy design. A dash indicates no intentional alloy range listed, rather than zero residual element. Selected heat-analysis ranges.
4037, 5140 and 4140 separate Mo-only, Cr-only and CrMo alloy design. A dash indicates no intentional alloy range listed, rather than zero residual element. Selected heat-analysis ranges. [2]

What the alloy buys in a thicker part

The center of a thick section cools more slowly than its surface. Greater hardenability helps the required hardened structure form at that slower cooling rate. It can also give the processor more latitude to select a quench that limits distortion and cracking, subject to the required core condition. [5]

The advantage of 4140 is its potential to harden through a section, not a fixed “4140 strength.” The hardness reached at the core depends on the heat’s hardenability, section size and quench-and-temper cycle. Annealed bar, prehardened bar and a finished quenched-and-tempered bolt can share the same base chemistry designation while having different properties. State the required delivery or final condition. [4] [5]

What 4140H adds

The H suffix identifies a hardenability-controlled grade. SAE J1268 gives H-steel hardenability bands based on the standardized end-quench test. An order for 4140H therefore includes a transformation-response requirement as well as a chemistry framework; use the applicable H-grade limits and band rather than attaching H to an ordinary composition certificate. [6]

For a fastener order, specify the raw grade, section size, delivery condition and required final mechanical properties. Where tempering behavior or core hardening drives the choice, include the required test or band. Compare boron-treated steels when forming is the main manufacturing constraint, or 8640 and 4340 where the alloy design also calls for nickel.

References

  1. SAE J404_200901 — Chemical Compositions of SAE Alloy Steels (revised January 2009)
  2. China Steel Corporation, Bar & Wire Rods Product Manual (2025), §§6.1.2, 6.1.16–6.1.18, pp. 13, 23–25
  3. Nippon Steel, Special Steel Strip, U112en, section on the effects of alloying elements
  4. voestalpine High Performance Metals, AISI 4140 technical description
  5. Metallus, Practical Data for Metallurgists, 19th edition (2024), pp. 4–7 and glossary
  6. SAE J1268_201005 — Hardenability Bands for Carbon and Alloy H Steels (May 2010)