Engineering Guide · 5 min read
American Steel Grades: SAE J403, J404 and ASTM F2282
An American fastener-steel family guide covering 1006, 1018, 1045, 1541, 10B21, 4037, 4140, 4340, 8620 and 12L14, with linked composition articles.
The short answer: American fastener steels are best selected by chemistry family and manufacturing route: carbon, manganese, boron, alloy or free-machining steel, followed by the required stock and finished-part specifications.
An American material callout becomes easier to use once the chemistry family and manufacturing route are clear. This guide covers carbon and low-alloy steels relevant to bolts, screws, nuts, rivets and related threaded parts. Stainless steels and tool steels have their own families.
Material-family articles
- Low-carbon steel — SAE 1006, 1008, 1010, 1018, 1020 and 1022 / J403: choose carbon and manganese for forming and the intended subsequent treatment.
- Medium- and high-carbon steel — SAE 1035, 1045, 1050 and 1060–1095 / J403: increase hardness potential while accounting for a more demanding forming route.
- Higher-manganese carbon steel — SAE 1522, 1524 and 1541 / J403: increase hardenability by changing manganese at a comparable carbon level.
- Boron-treated steel — SAE 10B21, 10B22, 10B33 and 10B38 / J403: combine effective boron with the carbon level needed by the part.
- Molybdenum, chromium and CrMo steel — SAE 4037, 4130, 4140 and 5140 / J404: assess section hardening and tempering response.
- NiCrMo steel — SAE 8620, 8640 and 4340 / J404: distinguish carburizing grades from medium-carbon hardening grades.
- Free-machining steel — SAE 1117, 1144, 1215 and 12L14 / J403: select bar stock for turned components.
What SAE J403, J404 and ASTM F2282 specify
Use SAE J403_202402 for carbon-steel chemistry and SAE J404_200901 for alloy-steel chemistry. ASTM F2282-23 addresses the physical, mechanical and metallurgical quality requirements for carbon and alloy steel wire, rods and bars in coils intended for fasteners manufactured cold. For a component machined from straight bar, specify the appropriate bar-product requirements. The finished bolt or screw also needs its applicable product and mechanical requirements. [1] [2] [3]
| Specification layer | What belongs here | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Material chemistry | Composition family and grade | SAE 1018 / J403, SAE 4140 / J404 |
| Incoming stock | Product form, dimensions, supplied condition and applicable defect limits | ASTM F2282 for the specified cold-manufacturing stock in coils; an appropriate bar specification for straight machining stock |
| Finished fastener | Geometry, final mechanical properties, heat treatment and finish | The specified bolt, screw or nut product requirements |
A heat analysis reports the composition of the steel heat; a product or check analysis tests a sample from the product. SAE J403 and J404 refer to SAE J409 for permitted product-analysis variations. When checking a certificate against a chemistry table, identify which analysis is reported and apply the corresponding limits. [1] [2]
How to read the grade name
In the familiar four-digit system, the leading digits identify a chemistry family and the final two digits usually indicate the approximate carbon level in hundredths of a percent. Thus 1045 is nominally around 0.45% C. The actual allowed range comes from the specification. B identifies a boron addition, L a lead addition, and an H suffix a hardenability-controlled grade. [4] [5]
“AISI 1018,” “AISI 4140” and “AISI 4340” are legacy designations. The cited SAE standards identify these as SAE grades. When ordering, specify the SAE grade and applicable purchase specification together. [1] [2]
Which family changes the material in which way?
The table summarizes the design choices. Composition details, source conditions and full selected-grade lists are in the linked articles above.
| Family | Representative grades | Material change | Selection priority |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low-carbon 10xx | 1006, 1008, 1010, 1018, 1022 | Low carbon, with grade-specific Mn | Forming strain, cold-work condition, surface-hardening route |
| Medium-carbon 10xx | 1035, 1038, 1045, 1050 | More carbon | Hardness potential and adequate core hardening |
| Higher-Mn 15xx | 1522, 1524, 1541 | More manganese at the selected carbon level | Hardenability and forming load |
| Boron-treated carbon steel | 10B21, 10B22, 10B38 | A small effective boron addition | Forming, active boron and the permitted tempering route |
| Mo / Cr / CrMo | 4037 / 5140 / 4140 | Different Cr and Mo combinations | Section hardening and tempering response |
| NiCrMo | 8620, 8640, 4340 | Ni with Cr and Mo; different carbon levels | Case versus through hardening, strength and toughness |
| Free-machining | 1117, 1144, 1215, 12L14 | Specified S, P or Pb additions | Cutting behavior and required finished-part ductility |
The carbon, manganese and alloy distinctions are drawn from the cited producer chemistry tables; the manufacturing comparisons follow the respective family articles. [6] [7]
A practical selection sequence
Start with how the component must perform and how it will be made. A deeply headed rivet favors deformable incoming stock. A carburized contact part needs a surface/core specification. A quenched-and-tempered bolt needs the required properties through its critical section. A turned spacer can put more weight on machining behavior.
For a hardened part, select a carbon level capable of the intended condition, then assess whether manganese, boron or alloy additions are needed to harden the actual section. Check the result after the specified tempering operation. If hardenability is purchased by an H band or a particular end-quench requirement, include that requirement in the order. [5]
Other American families include V-microalloyed, Cr–V and Si–Mn steels, with designations such as 10V45, 6150 and 9260. These serve more specific strengthening, spring or wear requirements. A proprietary no-final-heat-treatment product needs its own chemistry, supplied structure and process specification; its properties cannot be inferred from a familiar SAE base name alone. [8] [7]
What to include in a material request
- The finished part standard or drawing, dimensions and required mechanical condition.
- The SAE grade, applicable chemistry specification and any agreed tighter element limits.
- Wire, rod or bar size, supplied condition and applicable stock quality requirements.
- The hardening route and any required core hardness, case depth, toughness or hardenability test.
For the Chinese material families, see the Chinese GB/T steel-grade guide. Cross-standard replacement requires checking the full chemistry and part requirements; the two family guides provide the starting data for that separate comparison.
References
- SAE J403_202402 — Chemical Compositions of SAE Carbon Steels (stabilized February 2024)
- SAE J404_200901 — Chemical Compositions of SAE Alloy Steels (revised January 2009)
- ASTM F2282-23 — Quality Assurance Requirements for Carbon and Alloy Steel Wire, Rods, and Bars for Mechanical Fasteners
- SAE J402_202403 — New Steel Designation System for Wrought or Rolled Steel (stabilized March 2024)
- SAE J1268_201005 — Hardenability Bands for Carbon and Alloy H Steels (May 2010)
- China Steel Corporation, Bar & Wire Rods Product Manual (2025), §§6.1.2, 6.1.16–6.1.18, pp. 13, 23–25
- Metallus, Practical Data for Metallurgists, 19th edition (2024), pp. 4–7 and glossary
- Nucor, Hot-Rolled Steel Bar — published SBQ grade offering

